Law Office of Albert M. Afonso

 

                                                                                     TEL: 1.856.786.7000

Home Home | Legal About Us | Login Contact Us | Sitemap Search Site | FAQ Humor
Chinchillo
Crash suspect can't drive for 56 months

Friday, December 12, 2003

By RENEE WINKLER
Courier-Post Staff
CAMDEN

A Superior Court judge on Thursday refused a prosecutor's request to bar a man accused in the vehicular death of a South Camden nun from driving, pending the outcome of his trial.

The ruling in the case of Edward Chinchillo, of Williamstown, however, is moot.

Chinchillo learned Wednesday the state's Division of Motor Vehicles had suspended his driver's license for 56 months because of criminal charges resulting from the Dec. 20, 2002, accident.

Chinchillo, who has been free on $250,000 bail since Oct. 29, is charged with driving while under the influence of crack cocaine when his motor vehicle crossed into oncoming traffic on Burnt Mill Road. A passenger in the approaching car, Sister Margaret "Peg" Hynes, 69, died in the accident and the driver and a second passenger in the car were seriously injured.

Chinchillo's attorney, Albert Afonso, said he will appeal the suspension because his client was not notified of it. Afonso said he learned of the suspension from Assistant Camden County Prosecutor Brian Mulholland, who will handle the pending criminal case.

Also charged with manslaughter and two counts of aggravated assault is Chinchillo's wife, Janice, who remains in the Camden County Jail.

Mulholland sought suspension of Chinchillo's license as a bail condition, he said, because the defendant was a "clear, present, and continuing danger to the community."

Superior Court Judge Samuel D. Natal said any change in bail conditions would have to be accepted by Chinchillo's surety, who posted the bail. Natal said if residents see Chinchillo driving, they should notify police.

If the loss of his license were a condition of bail, a violation could return Chinchillo to the Camden County Jail.

Afonso told the court it would be several more weeks before he learns if the state's public defender's office will approve payment for experts, including a substance-abuse specialist and an accident reconstructionist, to help him prepare a defense. It is unlikely the couple would go to trial before next summer, attorneys said.

Janice Chinchillo's defense attorney, Ralph Kramer, said he is negotiating with the prosecutor's office for a possible plea deal for the woman.

After the accident, Edward and Janice Chinchillo told police they had smoked crack cocaine at least four times in the four hours before the crash. Janice Chinchillo told police she had put crack into a pipe for her husband and lighted it as they drove to the Echelon Mall. Edward Chinchillo was steering with his knees when he swerved into approaching traffic near a bend in the road.
 
Man is freed on bail in death of Camden nun

Inquirer Staff Writer
 

The man accused of driving a car that killed an activist nun from Camden has been released on $250,000 bail, authorities said.

Edward Chinchillo, 45, of Williamstown, who is accused of steering his car with his knees while smoking crack cocaine, faces charges in the death of Sister Margaret Mary "Peg" Hynes.

Chinchillo was freed shortly before 9 p.m. Tuesday, Bill Shralow, spokesman for the Camden County Prosecutor's Office, said yesterday.

He had been in jail since the December death of Sister Peg, who was killed when Chinchillo's 2002 Lincoln LS crossed the center lines of Burnt Mill Road in Cherry Hill, striking a 1997 Kia driven by Thomas Quinn, a friend of Sister Peg's.

Chinchillo's wife, Janice Chinchillo, 49, who authorities say passed a crack pipe to her husband, remains in jail, unable to make her bail, which was also set at $250,000 last year.

In June, a grand jury returned a 10-count indictment against the Chinchillos.

Officials allege that the couple made a drug deal in the parking lot of Echelon Mall in Voorhees on the night of Dec. 20.

Authorities said that the Chinchillos had both smoked rock cocaine at least four times in the four hours before the accident. At her husband's request, Janice Chinchillo loaded the crack pipe and handed it to him, authorities said.

The car began to weave, then it hit the car driven by Quinn; Sister Peg and Muriel Prickitt were passengers. The three were returning from dinner at a friend's house.

Quinn and Prickitt were both hospitalized. Sister Peg, 69, who was an advocate of affordable housing and a fixture at Sacred Heart Roman Catholic Church, was killed.

The grand jury charged both Edward and Janice Chinchillo with aggravated manslaughter, aggravated assault, and possession of cocaine.

Janice Chinchillo was also charged with child abuse, distribution of cocaine to a person under 17, tampering with evidence, and hindering apprehension. Edward Chinchillo faces charges that he endangered the welfare of a child.

Authorities say that Janice Chinchillo threw the crack pipe at a 16-year-old boy who was in the back seat of the car, after the crash but before police arrived. Edward Chinchillo had legal custody of the teen.

The teen originally faced drug charges, but they have been dropped.

The Chinchillos' next court appearance is scheduled for Nov. 17.


By JASON LAUGHLIN
Courier-Post Staff
CAMDEN
 

A jailhouse snitch spied on a Williamstown woman accused of involvement in a car crash that killed a nun, defense attorneys said Monday.

At a court hearing, lawyers for Janice Chinchillo, who is accused of passing a crack pipe to her husband, Edward, shortly before the fatal accident on Dec. 20, 2002, requested copies of any secret recordings held by the prosecution.

The Camden County Prosecutor's Office did not respond to the requests, said Bill Shralow, a spokesman for the office.

The claim emerged at a preliminary hearing for the Chinchillos, who are charged in connection with the death of Sister Margaret "Peg" Hynes, 69, of Camden. The nun died in a head-on collision on Burnt Mill Road in Cherry Hill.

Attorneys for the Chinchillos also said their clients had been offered plea bargains, said Shralow. The prosecutor's office did not respond to those claims either, he said.

The couple's next hearing is set for Nov. 17 in Superior Court here, Shralow said.

Authorities contend Edward Chinchillo was trying to steer with his knees while he smoked crack cocaine at the time of the fatal crash. Officials say he smoked crack four times in the four hours before the accident. Edward Chinchillo is charged with aggravated manslaughter and his wife is charged as an accessory.

Driver charged in nun's death


He was using crack when his car killed Camden's "Sister Peg," the prosecutor said.

Inquirer Staff Writer
 

The driver of the vehicle that killed an activist nun from Camden was steering his car with his knees while smoking crack cocaine, authorities said yesterday.

Edward Chinchillo's 2002 Lincoln LS crossed the center lines of Burnt Mill Road just south of Haddonfield-Berlin Road in Cherry Hill on Friday night, plowing into a 1997 Kia driven by Thomas Quinn, a friend of Sister Margaret Mary Hynes'.

"Sister Peg," as she was lovingly known by those she served in Camden, was in the front seat and died of cardiac arrest 20 minutes after the accident. A friend in the backseat, Muriel Prickitt, remained in satisfactory condition yesterday at Cooper Hospital-University Medical Center in Camden, where Quinn was in guarded condition.

Chinchillo, 44, of Williamstown, was charged with aggravated manslaughter and was arraigned yesterday. Bail was set at $250,000.

Appearing in an orange jumpsuit with shackles around his waist, Chinchillo spoke softly and asked Superior Court Judge Stephen W. Thompson for a public defender.

"I'll never make $250,000 cash," Chinchillo said softly when Thompson announced the bail.

His wife, Janice, 49, was arrested yesterday and charged with aggravated manslaughter because, officials said, she passed the crack pipe to her husband. She will be arraigned today.

Riding in the car with the Chinchillos was a 16-year-old boy for whom Edward Chinchillo had custody, law enforcement offices said. Authorities withheld his name.

The boy was charged with possession of crack cocaine and drug paraphernalia and was being held at the Camden County Youth Center near Blackwood.

According to Camden County Prosecutor Vincent Sarubbi, Edward Chinchillo had ingested large doses of crack at least four times in the four hours before he got into his Lincoln at Echelon Mall in Voorhees, not far from the crash site.

Sarubbi said that while heading north on busy Burnt Mill Road, Edward Chinchillo asked his wife to fill the crack pipe and pass it over. The prosecutor said that when Janice Chinchillo handed the pipe to her husband, he took his hands off the wheel and began steering with his knees.

Northbound Burnt Mill Road veers sharply to the right near Haddonfield-Berlin Road, and it was there that Chinchillo's car crossed the lines and slammed into Quinn's southbound vehicle.

Neither Edward Chinchillo, who authorities said was found with a crack pipe and a partly smoked marijuana cigarette, nor the boy was injured. Janice Chinchillo was treated for minor injuries at Kennedy Memorial Hospitals-University Medical Center/Cherry Hill.

Assistant Prosecutor James Conley said Edward Chinchillo acknowledged "thousands of previous ingestions" of the drug.

"Our investigation is ongoing, and we do anticipate filing additional charges," Sarubbi said. "He manifested an absolute indifference to human life."

Aggravated manslaughter carries a maximum 30-year sentence.

Public records show that Chinchillo owned E.J. Chinchillo Contracting Inc., based in Williamstown; owned a home valued at $238,000; and declared bankruptcy in 2001.

At the time he filed for bankruptcy, Chinchillo said he was disabled and was collecting monthly disability insurance and Social Security payments.

Neighbors said Chinchillo, whom they sometimes saw with the teenage boy, kept to himself.

The determined, tireless Sister Peg, 69, was a beloved figure in the troubled city of Camden, where she directed Heart of Camden Housing Corp., an arm of Sacred Heart Roman Catholic Church that rehabilitates abandoned houses and sells them at cost to poor families.

Most recently, she was Heart of Camden's development director, finding money for an agency that has helped more than 100 families own homes.

Yesterday, those who knew Sister Peg, a breast cancer survivor who grew up in North Philadelphia and loved Irish dancing, were still shaken by her death.

The Rev. Michael Doyle, pastor of Sacred Heart, remembered a woman who was equally comfortable around politicians and the poor, a nun who had a special love for the Vietnamese people of South Camden but had room in her heart for everyone.

"She was full of good humor. The first time I ever saw her face was in 1986, when she came here about taking on the job," Father Doyle said.

"I still remember that very first sight of her face and that smile. It was the most hospitable thing you ever saw."

Sister Peg's death, he said, leaves a terrible void.

"I would say a thousand times: You couldn't replace her," Father Doyle said. "How could you replace your own mother?"

In a statement yesterday, Bishop Nicholas DiMarzio of the Diocese of Camden expressed similar sentiments.

"Sister Peg's untimely and tragic death is an irreparable loss to the work of the church and the city of Camden," the statement read.

"She was known for her work with the Heart of Camden, but it was her own heart that she will be remembered for - a heart that made a place for Christ and all those she served in His name."

Dec 23, 2002 10:49 pm US/Eastern


CAMDEN, N.J.
(KYW) Prosecutors say the man who caused a crash that killed a Camden nun was smoking crack cocaine and steering with his knees.

Edward Chinchillo of Williamstown is charged with aggravated manslaughter.

Sister Margaret Hynes was a passenger in a car struck head-on by Chinchillo's vehicle on Friday night. Hynes was known as "Sister Peg" in Camden, where she worked to revitalize the impoverished city.

Chinchillo's wife also is charged with aggravated manslaughter.

Sister Hynes lived at the Holy Rosary Convent in Cherry Hill.

Officials say Hynes joined the Sisters of Saint Joseph in 1954 and spent most of her time at Sacred Heart Church in Camden. She had been the director of the "Heart of Camden" program, which helps the poor and homeless.

She was also a teacher and principal at Sacred Heart's school and had survived a battle with breast cancer.

Both a viewing and a funeral mass will be held for Sister Hynes next Saturday at the Sacred Heart Church. The viewing is from 3 to 7 pm. The mass will follow at 7 pm.

Main Site Areas
Attorneys ] DYFS ] Family ] Personal Injury ] Criminal ] Commercial ] Discrimination ] Immigration ] Real Estate ] Technology ] Wills ] News Media ]
 

Criminal - Aggravated Manslaughter

Judge refuses to drop charge in nun's death
Wednesday, May 12, 2004

By RENEE WINKLER
Courier-Post Staff
CAMDEN
 

A Superior Court judge has denied a defense request to drop aggravated manslaughter charges against a Williamstown woman accused of helping her husband smoke crack while he was driving, causing a fatal accident in December 2002.

A jury could find Janice Chinchillo "became an accomplice" in the death of Sister Margaret "Peg" Hynes, Judge Samuel D. Natal ruled Monday.

Natal will preside at the eventual trial of Janice and Edward Chinchillo.

Hynes was a passenger in a car that was struck when Edward Chinchillo's car crossed into the opposite lane on Burnt Mill Road in Cherry Hill.

A member of the Sisters of St. Joseph, Hynes, 69, had been a staff worker at Sacred Heart parish in South Camden from 1986 until her death. Each hearing for the Chinchillos brings members of the parish to the courtroom.

Investigators have said Janice Chinchillo, 50, had loaded a crack pipe and handed it to her 46-year-old husband, who held a lighter to the pipe, steering his Lincoln with his knees.

Janice Chinchillo's defense attorney, Ralph Kramer, sought to have the aggravated manslaughter charge dismissed before trial. Natal ruled that her actions were a "conscious disregard of the risk" created when her husband removed his hands from the steering wheel.

A pretrial hearing for the defendants had been scheduled for Monday, the deadline for them to plead guilty to avoid trial. Albert Afonso, attorney for Edward Chinchillo, asked for an extension of the plea deadline so a toxicologist could prepare a report on the effects of his client's drug use.

Natal said he was not inclined to postpone the case further, especially since the focus of the case that will be presented by Assistant Camden County Prosecutor Brian Mulholland "is not on the defendant's state of mind but on the circumstance of his actions."

Afonso persisted in his arguments, noting that the prosecutor would have to prove that Edward Chinchillo acted both recklessly and with extreme indifference to human life.

Natal set a June 1 pretrial date for the defendants. Because of Natal's calendar, it is not likely that the case would go to trial until late December of 2004, two years after the fatal accident.

Both Edward and Janice Chinchillo are in the Camden County Jail. If convicted they could be sentenced to up to 30 years in state prison.

 

21 Route 130 South
Cinnaminson, New Jersey 08077-2843 (click here for Contact Info; MAP & Directions)
Phone: (856) 786-7000  --  Facsimile: (856) 385-8181

E-Mail: Albert M. Afonso, Esq. @ mailto:albert@afonsobaker.com

THIS IS ADVERTISING PURSUANT TO THE PROFESSIONAL RULES OF CONDUCT 7.2

www.afonsobaker.com © 1996-2004 Albert M. Afonso, Esq. - All rights reserved 

(Hablamos Spanish - Español and Portuguese / Brazilian - Portugues / Brazileiro)